« Scared to Death (part 5) | Main | The case of the mystery Sikh »

Monday, 22 March 2010

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Nury

Hi guys, it's good to be back. I spent most of last week with live audiences and missed talking to readers.

All the Shanghai appearances were sold out and jam-packed, but one event in particular was tough.
I'd been up all night for reasons I won't go into on Saturday and the first audience I saw on Sunday morning was a packed hall of kids.
There were babies, including one who was 4 weeks old. There were grandparents. And there were teenagers, including some who seemed DEAD SET on spoiling the show for everyone, shouting out "toilet" at two minute intervals, long after it had stopped being funny.
My patience muscle grew miraculously that morning, I can tell you!
*
Thanks for the comments on the "Scared to death" story.

One commentator said that he expected a more creative form of poison such as snake venom etc.

Actually, the thing about detective stories is that creativity is nothing to do with whether you use poison a or b or c, but it lies in the method of "delivery" of the murder.

And the convention is that the reader gets the same clues as the detective.

So readers and the main character, Edna, both received the information that the victim and another person shared the ice water, and that the aircons were malfunctioning, and that the author insisted that the function took place in an obscure part of the world (where no forensic tests could be done).

So the reader and Edna end up racing to work out "whodunit".

The nicest comment I got was from an emailer who did not want her name printed, but whose letter said: "You don't need to write fiction in this spot, the stuff that you and your 'gang' get up to is weird and funny and entertaining enough as it is."

There's truth in that. Although I guess there are slightly fewer dramatic, death-defying adventures in our real life than there are in mystery stories.

So far!

Foxlore

Welcome back Uncle N, glad you did not succumb to the many seductions of Shanghai and made it back to safe 'harbour' ;-)

fardel

Welcome back.
In French we use a word ;Shangailler which is equivalent to kidnap;
I see with pleasure that Shangai let you go.
"And the convention is that the reader gets the same clues as the detective"
i thought that you were not following conventions. which is why I was disappointed

Mystery reader sometimes writer

dont listen to Fardel. Please stick to the convention of clues. Fardel;, If you write detective stories without the convention of giving out clues to the readers, you end up with a case that the reader can never solve and its no fun.
if you get clues at the same speed as the detective gets them, then you are "accompanying" him so to speak.

Lurker

I think it's also fun if the reader can solve the mystery but the detective character cannot.

Lia

Nury, is that you? (referring to the first picture)

fardel

Sorry guys
Unable to write more than six lines at a time on one subject, how do you expect me not know about the conventions on writing mystery novels?

Being un-conventional myself, how do you expect me to know about conventions?
I still like the idea of dry snake poison on the left side of the glass of water.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

READ THIS

Become a Fan

JOIN US


How to add a pic

  • Click here
    Then use the “Choose File” button and find the picture on your computer. See the word "Resize"? Choose: "Website/email", and upload. In a box called "HTML For Website" you'll find a code to paste into your comment

FREE subscriptions

  • Fill in your email and you'll never miss an issue. We don't pass your email address to anyone else, and you can cancel easily with a click from any issue.

Your email address:


Powered by FeedBlitz

The Diary is Open

Bookmark and Share

The Information

How to add a pic

  • Click here
    Then use the “Choose File” button and find the picture on your computer. See the word "Resize"? Choose: "Website/email", and upload. In a box called "HTML For Website" you'll find a code to paste into your comment
My Photo

For Asian news


Faces

  • Some regular commentors

Good reads


  • A young woman joins a feng shui agency expecting to spend her time arranging furniture. But then she discovers Mr Wong specializes in examining the harmony or lack of it, at scenes of crime

  • Comedy-crime caper in which a Mr Wong and his assistant travel from Singapore to Australia in pursuit of a girl who seems destined to die

  • Mr Wong and his assistant go on a multiple-country tour and solve many puzzles on the way

  • Mr Wong gets involved with Uyghur freedom fighters and Chinese-American geopolitics in this, the most hard-hitting and thrilling volume of the series

  • The feng shui detective, facing financial ruin, agrees to tackle a mystery on the world's biggest jet, in the funniest book of the series

  • Illustrated book for under-eights. In a land where there are no stories, two children find letters of the alphabet and try to make tales which will kickstart their imaginations

  • Jeri Telstar is new breed of superhero. He doesn't solve his problems with violence. Instead he uses his homework to trick supervillains into submission. Ages 8 to 11

  • In the second of the series, the homework hero has to solve the mystery of the misbehaving president. And as always, he avoids violence and uses his brain